Hakani – paving a road to hell

In this Q&A, Survival’s former director Stephen Corry explains why Survival is against Hakani.

Extracts below:

You object to the film ‘Hakani’. Why?

Stephen Corry: It’s faked. It puts together footage from many different Indian tribes and uses trick photography to make its point. It wasn’t filmed in an Indian community, the earth covering the children’s faces is actually chocolate cake, and the Indians in the film were paid as actors.

The filmmakers say it’s a re-enactment, not a fake. How do you respond?

Stephen Corry: It’s presented as entirely real. The opening title of the complete film reads, ‘A true story’, and only at the very end is the viewer told it’s a re-enactment. The trailer, which has been seen by far more people, doesn’t mention it at all. If it were broadcast here, that would be mandatory.

If [the infanticide] happened as portrayed, it’s an extraordinary isolated case. After decades of working in Amazonia, we know of no Indian peoples where parents are told to kill their children. It just doesn’t happen.

Why oppose the film if it’s just trying to stop infanticide?

Stephen Corry: The film and its message are harmful. They focus on what they claim happens routinely in Indian communities, but it doesn’t. It incites feelings of hatred against Indians. Look at the comments on the YouTube site, things like, ‘So get rid of these native tribes. They suck’, and, ‘Those amazon mother f—-ers burrying (sic) little kids, kill them all’. The filmmakers should be ashamed of all the harm this film is doing to the people they are trying to help.

It’s propaganda to bolster the evangelical campaign for a very dangerous principle, the so-called Muwaji law, which has been presented to the Brazilian Congress.

What’s that?

The Muwaji law focuses on what it calls ‘traditional practices’ and says what the state and citizens must do about them. The original text says that if anyone thinks there is a risk of ‘harmful traditional practices’, they must report it. If they don’t, they are liable to imprisonment. The authorities must intervene and remove the children and/or their parents. All this because someone, anyone, a missionary for example, claims there is some risk.

A further draft of the Muwaji law approved by a commission in June 2011 does not
mention the removal of children. However, the evangelical sector in Brazil wishes to
bring the enforced removal of children back into the draft. It is not known which
version, if any, will be finally passed into law.

Read more online at Scribd.com or download the PDF.
Read Survival’s response to the Hakani film team’s comments.
h2. From the web

* Hakani on Youtube
* Video: Suruwaha Indians criticize Hakani film
* Hakani article on Wikipedia
* USA Today article on Hakani
* Hakani official website
* Youth With a Mission – creators of Hakani film
* Brazilian Anthropological Association article (in Portuguese)

From Survival

* Hakani Q&A with Stephen Corry
*  ‘Hakani’ Entrevista com Stephen Corry (Em português)
* Read Survival’s response to the Hakani film team’s comments


Sign up to the mailing list

Our amazing network of supporters and activists have played a pivotal role in everything we’ve achieved over the past 50 years. Sign up now for updates and actions.